INDIANAPOLIS — In 2023, Kelsey Mitchell was named an All-Star for the first time as she posted 19.4 points per 36 minutes. That mark ranked 19th in the league, very strong but not elite from the Indiana Fever guard.
Mitchell, to that point in her career, had always refined her craft. Some aspects of her scoring — volume, efficiency, or a combination of the two — always improved and showed up in one statistic or another. Since then, though, things have taken a turn. But not downwards. Rather, they’ve gotten significantly better even after Mitchell became a star.
In 2024, Mitchell’s per-minute scoring and field goal percentage climbed. One year later, her scoring rose again as her accuracy fell by just one percentage point. And this season, the now four-time All-Star has seen her numbers rise once more — her points per 36 minutes (25.8) and field goal percentage (49.5) are both career-best marks.
“I think just her efficiency and the way she does it consistently,” Fever guard Caitlin Clark said when Mitchell’s improvement looks this year. “She’s amazing. Everything that she does is top tier… every time she shoots the ball, I feel like it’s going to go in.”
Rep The IX Sports at your next game!
Shop the logo collection or special “Women’s Sports are Front Page News” collection now on Shopify.
Recently, that has felt even more true. Mitchell has scored 20+ points in 10 consecutive games, becoming just the seventh player in WNBA history to do so. She’s knocked down 51.7% of her shots in that stretch. Half of her threes have gone in. Mitchell has been impossible to stop.
Her lowest point total in that stretch is 20, and she knocked down 43.8% of her shots in that outing. Mitchell’s worst field goal percentage across those 10 games is 38.9%, and she finished with 27 points that night in a 16-point win. As a team, the Fever are 7-3 in that stretch.
The numbers tell a story, and it’s that Mitchell can’t be stopped this season. She’s up to fourth among qualified players in points per minute this season, trailing only A’ja Wilson, Chennedy Carter, and Marina Mabrey.
“She just loves to play,” Fever head coach Stephanie White said of Mitchell’s scoring growth continuing, even still. “She’s just a baller. She loves to play. She’s always in the gym, she’s always working on her game.” White pointed to Mitchell learning to play at different speeds as being important to her recent growth. She has more methods of producing points.
Mitchell has 18 20-plus point games in 2026, which tops the WNBA. Her four 30-plus point outings this season ranks third, only behind Mabrey and Wilson. Critically for Mitchell, the team plays well when she’s busy on the scoreboard — the Indiana Fever are 10-5 when she scores 22 or more points in a game this season and 6-5 otherwise.
The accolades could truly be endless. Mitchell continues to improve even in her age-30 season, and this weekend the Ohio State product will play in her fourth consecutive All-Star game.
Yet for Mitchell, these honors aren’t the point. Instead, statistical brilliance is a requirement for her team to win. And that’s what she is chasing: that victory feeling.
Saturday night, the Indiana Fever hosted, and defeated, the New York Liberty. Mitchell took 14 shots and made 10 of them on her way to a season-high 33 points. It was a mammoth performance, and the Fever came back from down 12 in the first half to win by 20.
Mitchell was a guiding force, and this came one day after Mitchell scored 30, including 17 during the first quarter, to lift her team over the Seattle Storm. That’s 63 points in 24 hours. Not bad.
The nine-year pro was set to field questions postgame and sat behind a microphone with Aliyah Boston at her side. Before any inquiries were sent Mitchell’s way, a Fever official shared many of Mitchell’s numerical accomplishments.
“What?” Mitchell reacted as the stats began to be read. She looked at Boston and asked her a question. Boston smiled. Mitchell, uncomfortable as her praise filled the room, put her head in her hands as it was revealed that she tied the Indiana Fever franchise record for 30-point games in a season. It was her 41st consecutive outing scoring in double figures.
“Damn,” Boston muttered into her microphone halfway through. Mitchell was still not amused. The first question of the press conference went Boston’s way, and she praised Mitchell’s work ethic for playing a major part in her never-ending ascent. “She can just score any way she wants at any point.”
Then, Mitchell was asked why she looked almost uneasy as her numbers were shared. “Definitely grateful. Definitely humble,” she began. “I just think there’s always a bigger purpose behind it. I’m not a stat person. Obviously, we play to win a game, and that comes with scoring points. I appreciate it. But it ultimately comes down to just… Not getting too high, not getting too low. I think that you get too high into it and you lose your mind. I don’t want to lose my mind.”
Mitchell went on to credit her teammates and the Indiana Fever organization for her success. Improved chemistry has helped Mitchell score more often, and it lifts her teammates, too.
Moments later, she is told about her streak of 20+ point games. “Damn!” Boston blurted out again, louder this time. Mitchell replied quietly at the same time. “Oh, nice,” she said before hitting Boston on the shoulder.
“I think it’s the flow,” Mitchell explained of her success in that stretch, feeling like she’s able to put the ball in the basket more often when her team can flow from defense to offense quickly.
Listen now to The IX Sports Podcast and Women’s Sports Daily
We are excited to announce the launch of TWO new podcasts for all the women’s sports fans out there looking for a daily dose of women’s sports news and analysis. Stream on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or anywhere you listen to podcasts, and make sure to subscribe!
It’s all calm for Mitchell. In games, she’s very serious. When talking about herself, her voice is level. Her actual play is anything but calm — it’s built on speed and an uncontainable inside-out game. But her personality is a foil.
It’s a quiet dominance. Mitchell is not a talker, per her own admission. “It’s about the game. If we ain’t talking about anything that got to do with basketball, then we ain’t talking at all,” Mitchell said. “I think that’s just my mentality. I don’t have time to be talking to nobody… They always laugh at me like I’m old, but really I just don’t have time. It’s about me finding the stuff that matters and makes sense.”
Boston laughed as “old” came out of Mitchell’s mouth, then after Mitchell finished her answer, Boston said “I love you so much.” The on-court chemistry that is helping Mitchell shine was right there in the postgame press room.
Guided by winning and those relationships, Mitchell just keeps scoring. And the Fever rely on her. Mitchell leads the team in minutes, toggles between on and off-ball roles, and never misses a game. In some ways, her personality is robotic. Her game, and what Indiana asks her to do, is far from it.
After her 33-point outing against New York, White called Mitchell a “hooper,” and a “ballplayer,” who doesn’t care about her numbers. Instead, she just cares about winning. White has been watching Mitchell since before her college playing days and knows her mentality well. It’s carried into her play, even to this day.
It’s jarring to see a player produce so much yet not care about the stats. Yet that’s who Kelsey Mitchell is, and her stoicism connects that thinking with her on-court performance. Her expression rarely shifts. Yet on Saturday, for just one moment, Mitchell cracked.
Deep into the second half of that Fever win, Mitchell was fouled while she canned a three and netted a four-point play. It was effectively the dagger in victory. After the contact, Mitchell fell onto the hardwood and landed across the sideline, which is where she lay when the whistle blew.
“Becoming Caitlin Clark” is out now!
Howard Megdal’s newest book is here! “Becoming Caitlin Clark: The Unknown Origin Story of a Modern Basketball Superstar” captures both the historic nature of Clark’s rise and the critical context over the previous century that helped make it possible, including interviews with Clark, Lisa Bluder (who also wrote the foreword), C. Vivian Stringer, Jan Jensen, Molly Kazmer and many others.
Clark came over to celebrate that shot and hovered near Mitchell with an ear-to-ear grin. Forward Myisha Hines-Allen stood over Mitchell and pretended to hit her in the chest over and over. Boston, also impressed, proudly waited a few feet away.
And with the game all but decided and her teammates elated nearby, Mitchell smiled for several seconds, a rare in-game sight. “It’s just cute,” Clark said of the play the next day, still smiling. “I don’t know if she’s ever surprised by what she does. But that three, I think she was almost a little surprised that it went in.”
Any four-point play is, to some extent, a surprise. But perhaps for Kelsey Mitchell, who keeps scoring and keeps raising her own level since that first All-Star nod, maybe making a difficult shot shouldn’t be a surprise at all.
